I don't get people saying Caitlin is too thin, while also saying the other women are fat. Technically they are to varying degrees, but she seems a healthy size.
Everyone seems to be different types of terrible. Lying about finances is terrible, using someone for money is terrible, manipulation is terrible, they're all terrible.
The proposal seemed nice. Did the box light up? The location seemed a little strange though. I've been there and seeing a street magician there is a tad unusual. Having a baby at 40 probably isn't the healthiest thing though, even for a man it can increase the probability for certain issues.
I can't blame the production crew for not telling any of them certain things. That's against their job. They'll get fired. They can't interfere as much as people think. They can push certain events to happen, but there are a lot of limits.