I totally think that her eyebrows were tatoooed on based on the way the light reflected on her face. The reflection was the exact same for her skin as it was for the "eyebrows". If they were penciled in, it would have been duller there. Yes, I really studied this during the episode. What I didn't get, and maybe at 40 I'm just too old to know what the kids are up to these days, is that out of the millions of people that are on social media, that many people picked out this girl's pictures and used them for nefarious purposes. And she just happened to run into a "victim" randomly? Also, as was pointed out in the podcast and by cometcupid - why was there no exploration into reporting these as fake pages to facebook?