Ritamarie2344

Originally I never thought it was Wilden but when they showed the video of Charles' bday. It hit me!! Omg it's a mini Wilden! The haircut and big ears, then I watched the first episode again. Right before the A text Wilden approached the girls, then he kept watching them, and he was obsessed. Also another clue I thought of, was when he goes up to Hanna leaving the mall and tells her that he doesn't care if her and her little friends were drinking that night. Like how else would he have known about that unless he was there that night. And I don't remember anyone saying he was involved in all the drama the day Ali disappeared.

So I personally don't think Wren is A or even who Ali saw bc Wren and Ali have technically never met on the show. By the time Ali came back Wren was already in London and Ali was missing when Wren came to Rosewood. So it just wouldn't make sense to me. I like the Wilden theory bc we were never really told he and Ali hooked up. Younger Charles in the bday video looks like a mini Wilden and Wilden did party outside of rosewood with Jason and Ali and Cece. Plus he's the right age. I also think he seemed obsessed with the missing Ali case. But what I still don't get is the whole Charles dying at 16 but yet he somehow escaped the same night as Bethany. Unless Mona was making that part up to throw the girls off bc she just said Leslie said and it was never confirmed and we all know Mona is the biggest liar. So with that presented I would say my theory is Charles is Wilden.. Charles killed Toby's mom while having a psychotic breakdown. Jessica then had Charles death faked and took him out of Radley. Since no one knew about Charles in rosewood outside of Radley it was easy for him to take on the Wilden persona.. i think Mona is red coat and Cece or Sara is black widow. I also think Bethany tired to kill Ali and then Charles hit Bethany. And Mr Hastings had to know about Charles bc he's Jason's dad. Maybe the deal he had with Jessica was really about covering up that Charles was still alive.

Speaking of timelines: what I want to know is: When Mr D tells Jason and Ali about Charles, he tells them Charles is their older brother and 15mos older than Jason. Mr D says that Charles was committed to Radley after he tried to kill Ali when she was a baby. He then convinced a 5yr oldish Jason that Charlie wasn't a real person. Jason then asked how did no one in Rosewood wonder or ask about what happened to Charlie. Mr D then states that they didn't move to Rosewood until Charlie was in Radley bc Mrs D wanted to be close to him and Charles was kept a secret. He then tells them that Charles die when he was 16 while in Radley. There are even records from Radley stating this. Ok so in the show Ali is about 17/18 Jason is about 24/25 that would make Charles 26/27. So if Jason bio dad is Mr H, how the hell did Mrs D and Mr H get it on if they didn't live in Rosewood yet. So let's say they met somewhere outside of Rosewood, don't you think Mr H would know about Charles? Especially since Charles hadn't been committed yet???? Next weird timeline is the whole Bethany, Lesli, and Charles being committed at the same time. Okay so Bethany and Lesli are the liars age so 17/18 and of course Charles is older by almost 7yrs. Radley's records show Charles dying at 16. But later on Mona says that Lesli states that Charles escaped the same nite Bethany did. So I get that Mrs D would hide their son from Mr D if he escaped. But why would Radley file reports of Charles death and still have him committed for 7 more years while he is alive??? That makes zero sense!! I'm confused!! What do yall think?