Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

Margherita Erdman

Member
  • Posts

    233
  • Joined

Everything posted by Margherita Erdman

  1. I saw Stella, and saw her perceiving her own "clear purpose," as Rose enviously put it, as a protector and mentor of women, a role Stella saw herself as uniquely suited to fill in the male-dominated police force and a still-patriarchal society in which women and girls are especially vulnerable. My read of Stella's relationship to Spector throughout the series is not as her subterranean psychological shadow self or secret desire but more simply the personification of everything she fights against in her professional and personal life (since there is little distinction between the two). As an incredibly violent sexual predator with no conscience, he is her perfect nemesis.
  2. Hated watching Robert Gossett die on screen for the second time this year. Found Dr. Charles' outrage about lack of consent baffling — does lack of informed consent by the patient or next of kin/designated proxy really take absolute precedence over life-saving treatment? Dr. Char.es certainly seemed to think the patient's problem was urgent when he was dressing down the ED doctor for missing the correct diagnosis. Also baffled by the mysterious comings and goings of Nurse YaYa's TB. Can it suddenly become an acute problem after a course of suppressive drug treatment? Has TB become chronic and incurable again, a relapsing/remitting disease? Why isn't she cured? If she'd been diagnosed with a drug-resistant strain she would have been subject to strict quarantine and much more intense treatment right? Ugh, the Noah & Halsted trapped in a subplot.
  3. @lordonia, I only remembered to watch it yesterday because it popped on my home page as it has every Wednesday. Must have to do with my viewing choices. [Mindy has never shown up on my home page I don't think except maybe in a slide show spotlighting Hulu originals.] And did I miss something (nodded off maybe)? Was there a preview somewhere that there would be a death in the finale? Does it have to be only one? IMO they're all nitwits, ciphers, or paper-thin stereotypes (the abusive husband/dirty cop, the tough guy whose enigmatic is waaay too try-hard) — — except for the daughter, the therapist, and the assistant. They can stay. Wouldn't that be some kind of show? A middle-aged African-American therapist becomes guardian to a young teenaged girl after the tragic loss of the girl's parents. They are joined by a pregnant Asian-American graduate student in neuropsychology and have interesting adventures in forensic detective work.
  4. You are right, I was dashing off a post and I should have been more clear that I was rating Daredevil only by my own lights. As I have had reason to discover, all of the Marvel Netflix shows are and will be rated TV-MA, but they have very different qualities, and because the Marvel name and cast of characters (and home-based accessibility through Netflix) are so attractive to the middle-school set, we parents of those middle-schoolers are trying to sift through the shows and decide one by one what we will let them watch. Just look at the reviews and recommendations on Common Sense Media (a site/app devoted to helping determine what media content is appropriate for what ages) for these shows and you'll see they range from ~11-18. I totally get why Marvel wants to keep its blockbuster movie properties mostly PG-13 (saying no to Deadpool was also an unpopular decision in our house) and then create a space for consistently adult content in streaming, but it is a pain in the ass if you have a kid who's not a little kid but not an mature older teen, either. So — Daredevil was a no for my son at first, just to be on the safe side, but then it became clear that most of his friends were watching it, not to mention a family friend was deeply involved in its production and to my Asperger's-type son it felt disloyal and hypocritical to avoid it (especially when said family friend has a son his age who had of course seen it all), so I finally caved and in the end decided that while violent, Daredevil is literally comic book violent, and the characters are drawn in pretty broad strokes, and there's no complicated sexual stuff, so, you know, whatever. [Yeah, yeah, awesome parenting, but I'm hoping that some of you either remember being 13 or have some experience parenting a 13-year-old and know that you pick your battles.] Jessica Jones was and is a hard no because of the intense psychosexual violence, as well as the sudden and arbitrary acts of extreme personal cruelty, depicted and implied. Luke Cage is a weird one. Like I said, I think the racial and social content is more problematic for a younger audience than the sex and violence. I have been having some interesting conversations about the show with my son and his friends who are watching it.
  5. That was my initial reaction too, when I saw that Spector was well and truly going to succeed at suicide: super-frustrated with the storytelling and feeling like the whole season was for nought. However — ^ @WearyTraveler sums up the realization I had when Stella Gibson confronts Spector's corpse on the floor of the Foyle Clinic, and the pieces slid into place for me and suddenly the entire series felt like a story well told. Stella got smug and showed her hand to Spector when she told him why she said "we're losing him," and he deprived her of the justice she craved. She sees what he did, and she sees her part in it, as she has seen her part in everything else that has happened as the case has unraveled. IMO it's a credit to GA's acting and the staging of that scene that so much is communicated without words. I think there are many nuances and ambiguities allowing for interpretation in the denouement of this story, but the Telegraph's recap as you describe it is just way, waaay off in the broad strokes. The neuropsychologist specifically requested that Dr. Larson concur with her that Spector was malingering with regard to the amnesia, and everything we were shown or told about Spector indicated he was incapable of feeling guilt or shame or any kind of regret at all for his crimes or for the impact that his behavior had on those around him, like his wife and children.
  6. Gracious! This show is boring. Even @saoirse knows it isn't worth the effort to post the episode summary ;) I also hate riddles. Usually a compulsive completist, I may have to go with assistant Christine on this one and take my leave early. The Palais des Beaux Arts was shot beautifully though.
  7. Great rundown, but note to editors: "doff" means to take off, not put on. And the fact that's all I have to say makes me realize that I'm doing a lot more hating than watching this show. It's all about James Spader for me. Wrap him up with Dembe and Panabaker and Harry Lennix and whatever's left of Mr. Kaplan and maybe they could take the show on the road.
  8. Funny you should say that! I just watched the documentary Code Black that apparently inspired this show (it's streaming on Netflix) and when the filmmakers started shooting in 2008, it was in the original LA County hospital building finished in 1932, which had an trauma and emergency department that was old and small and crowded (and not designed even to function as an emergency department, since such things did not exist as part of a fully-fledged, purposeful discipline until the 1970s-1980s (something I learned from the documentary). So in the old building, there actually was a "C-Booth" area just like "Center Stage" in the TV show, it looks like utter chaos, and the whole thing really looks a mess. The facility was so antiquated that the hospital had multiple waivers from federal, state, and county regulations governing privacy and all sorts of other things because the physical building simply precluded compliance. By a few years later, the documentary shows the relocated ED in the new building, everything shiny and new and HIPAA compliant, no more crowding and screaming and in everyone else's business. But that wouldn't make for anything like as good TV. Even the residents, in the documentary, who have come from the old building to the new sort of lament the loss of drama that drew them to the County-USC ED originally... That is definitely true, along with all the other absurdities you cite — but there is a tiny kernel of general truth in there that sadly, the vagaries of the healthcare economy have led to so many emergency dept and emergency room closures in the LA region that for many, including the poor and uninsured, County-USC is their only option.
  9. Not just any mental illness! The blah-de-blah erotomania blah-de-blah De Clérembault's syndrome boils down to our hero was a delusional stalker. Because that seems highly sympathetic and curable! I think it's supposed to make the character more complex and his motivations more ambiguous but for me all it does is make him even more repellent and the last thing this show needs is more ambiguity.
  10. The blouse with the flying geese was gorgeous, Joan Watson perfection. That's all I could like about this episode. Everything else made me sick to my stomach. Overwhelmed parents killing their special needs kids, that really happens, and more than once an adult child with aggressive behaviors has harmed or killed a parent. These are issues that divide the special needs and disrrability rights communities in really painful ways and could have provided material for a good or even just decent case of the week. Instead we get the (IMO) deeply offensive "Mother's Little Burden" — a weirdly disconnected Stepford mom unlike any autism mom I know online or IRL, who talks about her child as if he's an object right in front of him. That's not gallows humor (IMO) but a strange tone-deafness and willful ignorance by the writers. During the entire episode, each family member's perspective and pain was explored except that of Owen's himself. Everyone on the CIU team seemed shocked and horrified by the severity of his disability and relieved, honestly, by his absence in the present. Coincidentally, and related because I think it reflects the same embedded, unexamined assumptions, just this past weekend at my book group (all of us are special needs moms, most of us with kids on the spectrum — book club is a time to get together as something other than "autism moms"), we got to talking about Of Mice and Men and why it's still required reading in schools. I love Steinbeck, but I think it's telling that here's a perpetual American classic with an inexorable tragic arc leading to death for the person with developmental disability. There's just no place for him in society. That's certainly the message I took from it when I read it in high school. Back on topic: my son isn't aggressive, and he's highly verbal, but his manner is odd, and watching the actor playing Owen bounce on the yoga ball with his eyes averted, well, that could be my son, and seeing that story told in that way with the person with autism little more than a prop — it made my heart sink. So sad even Hayley Atwell's shiny hair couldn't redeem it for me.
  11. Wow, judging from this forum (and my own struggle to stay awake when watching it), the show has aimed for noir and landed on soporific. I like Chance's grad student assistant. I wish she'd been brought to the foreground before this episode because she, along with Lisa Gay Hamilton, bring the show alive. Everyone else is such a drag, living, as Eldon himself describes, in places of existential dreeeaaad. Beckett this ain't.
  12. With one new intern down already (sorry never learned her name), can Angus pull the plug for real on his brother (don't know his name either) and then we could have Christa & Neal back? We can keep Rob Lowe.
  13. Yes! I kept thinking that's not the mole you have to worry about — a much deeper joke than this shows creators are capable of writing consciously! though I wouldn't be surprised if Spader ad-libbed the line and Dembe (don't know that actor's name) rolled with it on the freckle response.
  14. I'm torn on this point. It's realistic slang. There's no need for code-switching when so few white people are around, right? And yet — my 13-year-old son has really been looking forward to this show (after being forbidden to watch Jessica Jones), and for his sake I was really hoping it would be a return to PG-13 like Daredevil. So far it looks that way except for the n-word. which encompasses multitudes he is not yet capable of understanding.
  15. You had me at Beebus (definitely using that!) but then maybe lost me at Preacher. However, the corgi *is* a compelling tiebreaker in favor.
  16. Seemed like "Serial" was the source for almost all of the setup and details for the case of the week. Step by step, almost. Made me wonder if this will be a ripped from the headlines kinda thing, and not in a good way, more of a do the writers have any original ideas kinda way. Atwell's bosoms deserve supporting credits of their own.
  17. Thank you I feel so much less alone now. We can be terrible together. She is a beautiful woman, and then her ears are just so — perpendicular. And large. How can anyone look at that footage (earage? sorry) and not think hmm, maybe a different hairstyle for this shot? I think about it until I've missed several seconds of [inane because Stella] dialogue. And now I am officially one of the bullying animals from Dumbo. Officially.
  18. Is anyone else watching this? Is anyone else mystified by the total absence of chemistry, any kind of chemistry, between Hugh Laurie or Gretchen Mol, or between Hugh Laurie and Diane Farr, and how that takes all the air out of what should be central tensions in the plot? Also, I am all for puncturing stereotypes, especially sex-based stereotypes, but I have been around a fair number of mathematicians and math-adjacent types, of both genders (mother was a math professor), and I have never known one to be so vague and — floaty — or reticent about boring one's companions with the details of a complex (to the layperson) axiom, or theorem, or concept.
  19. Put me in the U.S. Prime Suspect fan club (I think it helped that I saw it before being therefore inspired to binge the original on Netflix afterward, and could separate the two). Also I like Vertigo very much (though I loathe and question the sanity of the idea that it is a grand love story — but then, look at all those who think Trump is just a boy being a boy). Haven't seen Bosch, though I have read most of the novels and am hugely partial to LA noir in fiction and California noir more generally in film. That said — I have found the first two episodes (watched together) a little disappointing. From @Sarah D. Bunting's review: ^ Yeah, this, unfortunately, for me. It's as if Gregory House has changed specialties, lost his faith in medicine, and become a hopelessly sentimental, unfocused drunk given to mooning after unavailable, boringly enigmatic blondes rather than unavailable, sharp, put-together brunettes. Gretchen Mol still isn't happening for me, and D seems like a purely literary construct rather than a human being. It is all so very, very, precious. The cast, Gretchen Mol aside, is so very, very good though (Lisa Gay Hamilton!), and San Francisco so very, very beautiful, and the genre so very much my thing, that I'm sure I will see it through.
  20. I guess you & I now have the same To Do/Not To Do list, @candall! I have a health condition that requires constant monitoring and treatment, and once it put me in the hospital for an extended stay, so I've had blank forms to complete for living will, medical power of attorney, and advance directive gathering dust in a folder for quite a while, but it's this awful maudlin subplot has caused me to dig out the file and move it to the top of the pile on my desk. And I'm with you on both Oliver Platt and Daniel J. Travanti. Speaking of lists — add both of them to the growing list of Actors & Actresses Who Remind Me in a Particularly Dramatic Way That I Am Aging. @MakeMeLaugh has flagged this above, but there are many jurisdictions now that have taken the discretion/burden away from adult victims of intimate violence for reporting and prosecution. Massachusetts pioneered this approach 20-some years ago. I don't know what the system is in IL/Chicago, but it is no longer a given that a victim must personally come forward and press charges. This! Also it seems to me that surgery is a specialty well-suited to someone with Asperger's or an Asperger's-type profile. Bedside manner — not so important; precision, rote memory, devotion to process, intense curiosity in narrow fields of focus — awesome. Not sure that someone like that belongs in a teaching hospital though, except for something like Grand Rounds.
  21. Is it a requirement of all medical shows that there be an episode with a seemingly magical (possibly ghostly) patient who appears briefly to restore the faith of a doctor in his/her calling while (optional) saving an actual corporeal patient along the way, who then disappears, leaving the question of magic, ghosts, and the supernatural in doubt, but the doctor absolutely restored spiritually?
  22. Stella has been a frustrating and charisma-free character for me also, but the truth is that many abusive relationships are just like this with a push me-pull you dynamic. That's not victim-blaming — it's just the way it works. It's ironically Stella's independence and strength of character that doesn't ring true in this scenario — women (or the victims of whatever gender in the abuse dynamic) who have their own income and friends and support system are usually the ones who can get completely free and see their way clear. The final reveal, that she felt indebted to her ex for "saving" her from her own youthful problems with addiction and whatever else, almost made this make sense but in any case I hope the ex stays in Springfield. Also this is terribly shallow but I find Stella's storyline so annoying that over time I have found myself incredibly distracted by her EARS when her hair is pulled back. Am I the only one? The Louie arc is beginning to annoy the everloving shit out of me. I think this is the first episode in which the child has uttered a single word or shown any sign of attachment to either Casey or Dawson. He might as well be furniture or one of the toy fire trucks he's inevitably holding. Or, if it's a deliberate choice, then have them engage with the issue that he is a child with special needs who requires intensive parenting and special interventions. That could actually be interesting. And I totally agree that the main female characters are basically loons. The most stable, admirable, interesting-to-me-since-Shay-left women on the show are marginal to the main cast: Cindy, Connie, Donna. Yeah, that was incredibly gross, yet I couldn't look away. Oddly, I watched the first two episodes of Chance last night right before catching up on this dumb show, and there is a scene [spoiler alert] in which a guy very graphically gets his jaw half ripped off his face when he is smashed repeatedly against the edge of a dumpster. It was like a double feature of gore the likes of which very recently you would not see on broadcast teevee. (A) What was that about? Is that Insta-guy a real thing? I am an old, don't do Instagram unless it is to look at cute animal or child pics shared by family, and am really over the Severide-deals-with-his-angst-by-partying thing. (B) I was totally confused by Squad thinking the guy and his pool party and the power line rescue were totally cool instead of the guy being a douchebag wasting public resources and their time.
  23. It was a nice change of pace, for a fleeting moment, to have the focus not being on her as a character and be reminded that she has a lot of charm and skill as an actress when she's not enveloped in a pulsating neon glow halo of Mary Sue. I loved her on Lie to Me and she was fine on The Good Wife too, but on this show I spend most of her onscreen time wishing her into the cornfield. I actually like Sylvie — I think when used properly she has a 1930s screwball comedy vibe that fits nicely, and the secret-romance-novel-junkie-reveal, and collusion with Mouch, is an entertaining little subplot. Not just in characterization, but gah, a newly minted foster mom who goes to her firefighting shift in three layers of fake eyelashes and smoky eyeshadow and perfect contouring and a full berry lip in order to LOOK the part of a Goya madonna. I cannot overstate how much I dislike this storyline. It is still SO DIFFICULT and extremely rare for women to even qualify as firefighters anywhere in this country, much less hold their own in the physically and emotionally demanding (and often hostile, because of macho firefighter culture) environment. So to have a character get through and make it only to forget her "lifelong" dream of firefighting at the first maternal pang is appalling to me. And I say that as someone who radically rerouted my own career because of motherhood. I have no problem with that; it is a real and genuine thing. I just think it is irresponsible and repellent to romanticize the pull of a child to throw away a dream in a traditionally male-dominated profession, especially on a network TV show that could otherwise inspire girls and women to think of themselves in that profession, and normalize the idea of woman firefighters for the world at large (without also normalizing the idea "but they'll jump off that truck as soon as they want babies"). Just, yuck.
  24. This episode really seemed like a generic medical show to me — what unfortunately I thought would happen with the cast changes. Everyone and every plot plot feels to me like a recycled, abbreviated pastiche of something done earlier and better on ER or St. Elsewhere or Grey's Anatomy or Night Shift or even Chicago Med or a dozen other forgotten shows. The one faint echo of the Code Black from last year was the lovely thread of the schizophrenic patient and his brother and the very moving trumpet solo of "Nature Boy" — that evoked the Lion King episode from last year and the best things about last season, for me, for just a moment. If there were more of that I might hang in with this show.
  25. I don't know, but Harriet will no doubt join them in the not-seen, not-heard off-screen ether very shortly. Whatever happened to the Supernanny/Personal Assistant that Meredith hired when Derek was commuting between Seattle and D.C. and Meredith had the grand epiphany expressed in voiceover that working mothers Need Quality Help??? That was the last time I remember the show grappling with work-life balance. I agree that what's troublesome about the incredible invisible Grey-Shepherd children isn't that children make for interesting storylines but that Meredith as a character from the beginning has been set up to value motherhood and childhood, that she wasn't going to take on being a mother if she didn't commit to spending lots of time with her children and having a genuine family life. That even seemed to be the rationale for abandoning everyone and everything after Derek's death to cocoon with Zola and Bailey during her pregnancy with Ellis. But now she's trashed that ethos completely for no apparent reason and she's got no conflict about it...
×
×
  • Create New...