I would tend to disagree with you Bronzedog. The best dancer doesn't always win. Alfonso wasn't trained at all in ballroom but what he had going for him, in my opinion, was the abiity to sell a dance to the audience. That's something that not even the best dancers always have, tho', yes, I'll credit this to his tim on stage learning to sell his tap dancing to a broadway audience. Corbin is the first name that pops into my mind. A phenomenal dancer who didn't win. We're all turned off by bad cancing after the novelty wears off, so the show has to give the public what it wants, some good dancing, personable contestants, and a journey. Your mileage may and probably will vary, of course, but that's how I see it.